Patrick Kinsella, BC Rail and the truth

Sometime back in early 2009 I was thinking about Patrick Kinsella.  About Patrick Kinsella and BC Rail to be precise.

Kinsella, it seemed, had a finger in just about every major project approved by the government of his close friend Gordon Campbell.  The two-time chair of the BC Liberal campaign never registered as a lobbyist but Kinsella was rumoured to be in and out of government offices on a regular basis.

The rumours about Kinsella’s involvement in BC Rail were extensive.  During the BC Rail trial it was said he arranged meetings between CN and the government.  He advised BC Rail on privatization others said.  But there was no conclusive evidence that he was involved in both camps.

In 2009 I worked with the crack NDP research team to try and nail some of these rumours to the wall, particularly his role with BC Rail.  But no record appeared to exist of a payment of any kind outside of the BC Rail corporate offices.

And then I remembered that there was one other repository of corporate financial records I had access to: the Legislative Library.  And sure enough it was there, the one publicly available record of almost $300,000 in payments over three years to Patrick Kinsella for his ‘advice’ on privatization.

The contract was untendered.   And questions about it went unanswered as the BC Liberals resorted to an unconvincing claim of sub judice to cover-up the involvement of the BC Liberal campaign chair and lobbyist extraordinaire in the sale of BC Rail to one of the Gordon Campbell’s largest financial backers.

Here’s the current Health Minister Mike DeJong on Kinsella’s situation in 2009:  “The honourable member chooses to make allegations that derive directly from information and material that are squarely before proceedings at the Supreme Court of British Columbia. It is, therefore, inappropriate to answer”.

When Stone Wally Oppal failed, it fell to the stonewall master to back him up.

As Gary Mason observed after the still unexplained plea bargain, those questions remain unanswered because the current Premier is continuing Campbell’s policy of refusing to answer questions and hold a Public Inquiry into the corrupt sale of the railway to a major Liberal contributor.

They also remain unanswered because media outlets refuse to look into the whole stinking mess after the trial was shut down by a suspect plea bargain.

Hundreds of thousands of pages of BC Rail related documents collected for disclosure during the Basi Virk trial now sit in government offices.

No media outlet that I’m aware of has sought disclosure, although many jumped at a small one-sided package carefully prepared by the Special Prosecutor which purported to show the government itself was innocent of any corruption.

All it really showed was the Prosecutor’s case.

So I filed an FOI request for all the documents released by the government to the defense during the disclosure process.  And I’ve received the first batch, about 700 mostly innocuous pages.  Another 728 pages were completely redacted.  Blank.

Even with the somewhat dubious redactions there’s some very interesting revelations.  I wrote yesterday about the fake ‘lease’ process.  Over the next few days I’ll write about a shocking disclosure regarding the role of Patrick Kinsella.

This entry was posted in BC Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Patrick Kinsella, BC Rail and the truth

  1. Kim says:

    Excellent news Ian! Thank you, I’m sharing this. Many people will be happy to get new information on this file.

  2. spartikus says:

    The could have saved some trees and sent a single piece of paper with “x 768” on it.

  3. Ian Bateson says:

    Regardless of political stripe Ian, this (government off loading or hiding of real content) is—and has always been—the central problem in allowing government to operate without control. An independent government auditor—similar to the feds auditor general—is the only answer. I fear, regardless of who is in power, this will be long in coming to the province of BC.
    Thanks for the update and I will look forward to reading your next post obout this shocking affair.

  4. cfvua says:

    I can’t help but think how much better off we’d all be if our elected people could avoid being advised by individuals like you mention above. Or lobbied illegally by same.

  5. RossK says:

    Don’t know it would be shocking or not, but I sure hope that these docs might answer a question directed to Gordon Campbell by Joy McPhail in May of 2003 when, as you subsequently established Ian, Mr. Kinsella was ‘working’ for the not yet ‘leased’ BC Rail:

    J. MacPhail: A longtime Liberal Party fundraiser is Patrick Kinsella. He is the lobbyist for CN. Has the Premier or any of his ministers met with Mr. Kinsella and representatives of CN?

    In fact, if this question, which was asked in the legislature, could be answered using documents obtained by FOI request it would be most appropriate given Mr. Campbell’s response at the time:

    Hon. G. Campbell: I don’t have an answer for that. As the member opposite knows, if she wants to know about specific meeting times with either myself or the minister, she can do that through freedom of information.

    Details, sources and implications, of the question, etc., can be found here for anyone interested…


  6. Dreamer says:

    this is just the tip of the proverbial ice-berg…
    while you’re poking around, try to find out what business PK did for Vanoc, like which sponsorships did he sell and what were his commissions?

  7. Tinnay says:

    Well, how interesting that now our Liberal Government has decided to privatize iquor warehousing and distribution as shown on CKNW’s website today. Below is a copy of their report. I guess Chirpy Clark is following in Gordo’s footsteps!

    The BC government’s decision to privatize liquor warehousing and distribution could be very lucrative for a former political strategist for the premier, according to a blogger. Bob Mackin says “Progressive Strategies” has been lobbying the government on behalf of “Exel Logistics” to come up with a new liquor distribution system. Mackin says Patrick Kinsella is the chair of “Progressive”.

    “This is a very very lucrative contract and Exel is a very large company and if they want to get it privatized they have probably hired the right person for the job.”

    The Liquor Distribution Branch has warehouses in Vancouver and Kamloops and supplies 1400 retailers and eight bars and restaurants.

  8. Pingback: The Sh*t Has Hit the Fan « B.C. Beer Blog

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *